More often than not, I see/saw posts that it’s best to never sell minerals. My grandmother and aunt inherited minerals in Burke County, ND back in the 1920’s that carried forward to 1970 when my father inherited the rights. Always thinking “one day” something will happen, he died in 1996 with my mother taking charge then of the rights. She died in 2010 but passed on the rights to 3 of 5 children, I being one.
Dissention/suspicion for the possibilities began in 1965 so there was a long-standing, ill-feeling toward the “what if” and “who” would reap benefits, if anything but in 2012, sure enough, the Bakken area saw drilling and production happening.
I have no children, have no nieces or nephews that have ever given a rip about who I am, what hobbies I have enjoyed, made an effort to ever plan a visit and this, I feel, was compounded by 1 brother, their father, spinning a further tale of distrust when, according to law, in 2010 I had to do probate for our mother and one sister…one of the 3 that inherited the rights that also preceded our mother in death.
What I am getting at is this…at some point owning mineral rights becomes a headache. For some, like my family, it tore apart the good feelings towards one another, caused additional separation and now that I have 2 siblings left and no connection, facing end of life prospects as I age means parting with minerals.
How to do it? Who to sell to? What higher price you can get on speculation? How to deal with the “afterward” when a check is delivered and I mean (1) Capital Gains or (2) Taxes to include when (3) retired?
The obvious help is NOT there by others in the past from Landmen to the company who paid you royalties or if you live in a state “far-removed” from where minerals are obtained. Answers are vague that tell you to seek out a tax consultant and this is by those that often have bought/sold/exchanged.
My one person answer is that if long-term isn’t in your path meaning others to “bless” with the speculations you’ve had, then sell! Minerals are a gamble just as sitting at a roulette table in Vegas or buying a lottery ticket.
The philosophy is “it’s one more dollar that I didn’t have yesterday” can ring thru. If it isn’t costing you anything, hold on. However minerals need to be recorded and if a will is in your works, proper documentation needs to be done as you wash your hands of the unknown.