Robert -
Bad Landwork / Land Title Research is rampant in the industry right now, with all the very poorly trained kids that have flooded the market these past few years.
My Nephew came back from the Tarrant County Courthouse one day (I live in Fort Worth, TX, which is the County Seat) with a real quizzical look on his face. I asked him what was the matter and he told me how over the past several months he had been sharing a work table at the courthouse with a group of 7 other Landmen from another company (which, for the sake of peace in my life will remained unnamed).
He said how he had stood up about 2 that afternoon and started to pack his papers up when one of the other Landmen asked him if he was knocking off for the day. My Nephew replied "No, I'm headed to Probate, District Court and County Court".
In choir-like unison, the other 7 Landmen all asked "What are you going there for?"
These were Landmen who had been preparing Title Runsheets more than 5 years.
I am not an Attorney, but agree with you completely about your Clients' having a free well. If the property involved is in Texas, the Attorney I mentioned earlier is Board Certified in Oil, Gas and Mineral Law AND Civil Trial Law and extremely well experienced. He would probably take the case on a contingency basis and kick their ass.
Accept my offer to become A Friend on The Forum and I'll send you his contact information.
If what you say is true, the record title owners have the company over a barrel, which the company will very quickly come to recognize. The only recourse they could possibly have would be to sue the guy that signed for their Bonus Payment and any Royalties he has received back, but those issues may be contingent upon whether he warranted title or not.
They could maybe sue the Landman or Land Services Company that prepared the Title Runsheet for their money back from them, too.
As far as their getting to keep their Well goes, however, they'll have to throw money at the problem until it goes away.
Appreciate the faith -
Charles