Dear Mr. Sciacero,
You are mixing apples and oranges with your recitation of facts. If you collectively reserved 1/2 of the minerals, then you evidently signed a lease with EOG. Your net mineral acres would be 5 net mineral acres for the collective.
Then you talk about an NPRI, which has nothing to do with mineral acres. And you do not each own 2.5 royalty acres. A mineral acre is defined as a full mineral interest under one surface acre. A royalty acre is the full landowner royalty under one mineral acre. Typically, there are 8 royalty acres to the mineral acre.
IF you owned royalty only and the lease provided for 1/4 landowners royalty, AND the reservation of royalty was one-half of the royalty provided for in an oil and gas lease, then your brother and you would each own 1/4 of 1/4 or an 1/16 NPRI. You would have the same interest if you owned a total of 1/2 of the minerals and signed a lease for 1/4 royalty.
But you still have not arrived at your share of production. 10 acres will not support a well. To make things easy (ier) to understand, you first arrive at your tract participation factor. If a 320 acre unit was formed, your collective tract participation factor would be 5/320. Therefore 2.5/320 x 1/16 = 0.00048828125 of production (decimal interest each).
For real life numbers on the imaginary 320 acre unit, if the well produced 35,000 barrels of oil for the first month and you were paid WTI price, then the gross revenue for the unit should be about $88.00 x 35,000, or $3,080,000 (gross before taxes, operating expenses, etc). take your revenue percentage of 0.00048828125 multiplied by the gross revenue, then your gross revenue would approximate $1503.91 (each) for that particular month.
To further muddy the waters a bit, if you are a NPRI owner, a drillsite tract and unpooled, the jury is out in Texas as to horizontal drilling, but from an operational standpoint, the industry practice is to have the NPRI sign a division order and pay them accordingly, whether they ratify the unit or not.
There is a lot more to royalty calculations than meet the uninformed eye. For example, suppose the land came to you and a true NPRI of 1/2 of the usual 1/8 royalty was reserved by a prior owner. If you are a true royalty owner, then the reservation does not affect you in this scenario. HOWEVER, if you are a true mineral owner, then your percentage will be reduced by the previous reservation of the NPRI.
Best
Buddy Cotten